Based on actual events, this drama recreates the scene in 1971 North Carolina, when a school integration plan was opposed by local bigots, led quite openly by the Ku Klux Klan. It recreates, in remarkable detail, how an unlikely mediation, called a charrette, led to a civic compromise which few people believed could occur in that racially charged environment. And the denouement is genuinely surprising and rewarding.
Robin Bissell’s film takes its time to establish the facts and personalities of its story: after a fire at the black school, integration is pushed upon the community, and the segregationists push back. A charrette is agreed upon, forcing activists like Ann Atwater (Taraji P. Henson) to work closely with opponents like KKK president C. P. Ellis (Sam Rockwell) to find a solution everyone can accept to get the kids properly schooled. The story becomes a life lesson that working closely with people eliminates their differences and can bring them together in united purpose.
The factor that works against the film is that its conclusion is inevitable. Even if we had never heard of this conflict, it is easy to see where things are going to finish. Yet getting there is the reward. Sam Rockwell is tremendous, again, finding thoughtful nuance and evolution in his role. Taraji P. Henson is more one-dimensional, but creates a fiery personality that really doesn’t believe that justice will ever prevail. And when the pivotal moment finally arrives, it is delivered with real power and impact.
The Best of Enemies is a strong movie, a good historical record, and a valuable glimpse into human nature. It seems hard to believe now (and is certainly troubling) that so much opposition existed just fifty years ago in this country to basic human rights, yet recent events and attitudes have made this story relevant again. Thankfully, this story demonstrates that people can compromise for the greater good, and that lasting friendships can result between former enemies. ☆ ☆ ☆. 3 July 2019.